Wagon Wheel Pizza
About Wagon Wheel Pizza
At Wagon Wheel Pizza, we celebrate the charm of old-school New York pizzerias, where traditions run deep and every slice tells a story. Nestled in Wappingers Falls, our quaint establishment specializes in crafting delectable pizzas made with a family recipe sauce, served hot and fresh. Customers rave about our classic pepperoni, crispy garlic pizza, and the signature Square Wheel Special, all embodying the true taste of Italian heritage. Owned by the warm-hearted Peter, our cash-only, non-delivery approach enhances the authentic experience. Join us for a satisfying meal and relish the crispy, light crust that keeps pizza lovers coming back for more!
Menu Highlights
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Corona
lg Cheese Pizza
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
-
Great pepperoni pizza if you, like me, want it thin. Tried their side salad with Ranch dressing but a little too soaked with dressing , but fresh and tasty...
-
Great slices made how I remember. Post good crisp on the crust pretty good for Dutchess County
Frequently Asked Questions
-
What are the popular dishes at Wagon Wheel Pizza?
Wagon Wheel Pizza is known for its delicious garlic pizza and old-school New York-style pies, like the sausage and chicken pizzas. Many diners rave about the crispy crust and homemade flavors!
-
Can I make a reservation at Wagon Wheel Pizza?
Yes, you can make reservations, but walk-ins are also welcome!
-
What dining options does Wagon Wheel Pizza offer?
Wagon Wheel Pizza offers dine-in and takeout options, making it easy for you to enjoy your meal however you prefer.
-
What is the atmosphere like at the restaurant?
The atmosphere at Wagon Wheel Pizza is cozy and casual, perfect for families and solo diners alike. It’s a great place to enjoy a laid-back meal.
-
Is parking available at Wagon Wheel Pizza?
Yes, there is plenty of free parking available, both on-site and on the street.
Nearby Pizza restaurants
Are you the owner?
Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.
Claim this page
Wagon Wheel is indeed the best pizza in the area. Hands-down! Old-school New York pizza. No fancy toppings. Doesn't deliver. Only takes cash. Peter the owner is a delightful New York Italian. The menu online is outdated. It's more like $16-$18 per pizza now but still cheap compared to everywhere else. We get the garlic pizza (extra crispy) a few times a month. The best!!!